Monday, December 4, 2017

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Who watches the watchmen, who polices the police? It's a serious question asked by the Roman satirist Juvenal.

The Washington Examiner quotes a Tweet by Matt Drudge, founder of the Drudge Report, on the subject of odd doings at the FBI. Drudge is reported to have Tweeted:
We know what happens when one lies to the FBI. But what is the punishment when the FBI lies to us?
Or simply refuses to respond to legitimate Congressional inquiries? We may learn the answer to those conundrums sometime in the next two years.

Sunday, December 3, 2017

Exodus

Consider this another chapter in COTTonLINE's continuing series on the decline (and eventual fall?) of California, the once-Golden State. The Los Angeles Times has an article containing a half dozen mini case studies of educated young people who've left SoCal and moved to Las Vegas and elsewhere for economic reasons.

The basic issue: housing costs - outrageous home prices and exorbitant rents. The alternative being up to a 2 hour each way commute from an area with lower prices. None of these conditions apply in Nevada.

An indifferently maintained 1200 sq, ft. CA bungalow with 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, built 70 years ago might sell for half a million, depending on location. Scarcity creates apparent value - brutal conditions and ridiculous prices the result of nimby regulations and punitive fees on new construction.

When my father's people moved to SoCal before World War One, it must have been glorious. I wish I could have seen it. I really dislike the greater Los Angeles of today and avoid it whenever possible. San Francisco is no better. High population density is a bitch.

Later ... California reporter extraordinaire Dan Walters writes in San Jose's Mercury News that Federal data shows the state may already have set foot down the slippery slope of its next recession, one somewhat overdue by historical standards. When it arrives a recession is likely to raise anew many questions about whether CA's blue state high tax model is long-term viable.

The Last Thing ...

Read what Harvard Law prof emeritus Alan M. Dershowitz has to say about Special Prosecutor Mueller charging former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn with lying to FBI agents. His article appears in The Hill.
The second question is why did Mueller charge Flynn only with lying? The last thing a prosecutor ever wants to do is to charge a key witness with lying.

A witness such as Flynn who has admitted he lied — whether or not to cover up a crime — is a tainted witness who is unlikely to be believed by jurors who know he’s made a deal to protect himself and his son. They will suspect that he is not only “singing for his supper” but that he may be “composing” as well — that is, telling the prosecutor what he wants to hear, even if it is exaggerated or flat-out false.
You can be certain the legal team for anyone against whom Flynn testafies will makes those suspicions explicit in summation. Dershowitz concludes the lying plea reflects weakness, not strength.

Favoring Economic Growth

There is a lot of lying going on concerning the tax revisions being enacted by a Republican Congress. You will undoubtedly read that it will raise taxes on the middle class, and it may. What hardly anybody will tell you is this, from RealClearPolitics:
America is a dynamic country. A year from now, after tax reform passes, many unemployed people will be working again for the first time in a long time. Guess what? They will be paying higher taxes. Than zero. Putting people back to work does that.
Wouldn’t we (and they) rather they were at work, paying taxes for a change? Damn straight, everybody wins when that happens.

Having jobs may even slow the opiod crisis. Employed people aren’t sitting around feeling sorry for themselves, concentrating on their every ache and pain. “Productively busy” is how people function best.

Saturday, December 2, 2017

Tillerson ... Safe for Now?

After The New York Times article we cited earlier, which reported Rex Tillerson was on the skids as SecState, there have been further developments. President Trump has essentially denied the accuracy of that article, labeling it with his favored term "Fake News."

Lead author Peter Baker, while liberal as most of his NYT colleagues, is no rumor-monger. He believed he had good reason to write what he wrote, had at least two independent sources at a guess. So let's explore what may have gone wrong.

It is very clear the President and the SecState have held different views from time to time, no question about that. Trump underlings in the White House may have planned a SecState succession assuming quite reasonably the boss found these differences more irritating than he actually does.

Alternatively, the whole thing may have been planting a leak as a way to send Tillerson a message to shape up and get "on message" or resign. If Rex told POTUS "message received," maybe he really is in no immediate jeopardy. In that case Baker was used, and is probably furious with his "sources."

Or it may be that the notoriously touchy Trump truly was planning to dump Tillerson. Hating having his surprise leaked, he changed his mind just to muddy the waters and destroy the leakers' reputations as WH sources.

Tillerson had better hope this last wasn't the case. Trump can change his mind about personnel matters rather quickly; ask Gen. Flynn whose tenure as National Security Advisor lasted just 25 days!

Unlike government, business moves quickly to solve personnel problems. At NBC Matt Lauer went from $30 million man to unperson in less than a week. Trump does it “business style” when he can.

The Stealth Library Cat

How about something light-hearted for a change? Fox News has the story of Max, the Library Cat. He's a big, ginger cat who likes to sneak into the Macalester College library in St. Paul. The story has photos and considerable charm.

The librarians perhaps should put some live traps out to see if they, perchance, have been infiltrated by a few mice or even, horrors, rats. There is a good chance Max smells some elusive little furry prey lurking in the stacks.

I'm sure ts eliot didn't include Max in his practical cats compendium, clearly he should have done.

Saturday Snark

Instapundit Glenn Reynolds cracks wise about the Roy Moore special senate election about to happen in Alabama. Given the allegations of Moore’s youthful indescretions with gals....
If Alabama sends Roy Moore to the Senate, I think it will be for the same reason Caligula sent a horse: As a gesture of contempt.
Maybe ... or perhaps “lesser of two evils” is understood in AL as it is elsewhere.

Understanding the Mueller Witch Hunt

The attorneys who blog at Power Line provide a link to a National Review article by former Federal prosecutor Andrew C. McCarthy. In it, McCarthy lays out the underlying rationale of the Mueller “investigation.” Key quotes:
We’re in the wooly realm of counterintelligence, where anything goes. And in the event our aggressive prosecutor can’t find any crimes — which would be no surprise, since the investigation was not triggered by a crime — no matter: The special counsel is encouraged to manufacture crimes through the investigative process. Misleading assertions by non-suspects made to investigators probing non-crimes can be charged as felony false statements.

The end game of the investigation is the removal of Donald Trump from the presidency, either by impeachment (which does not require proof of a court-prosecutable crime) or by publicly discrediting Trump to such a degree that his reelection becomes politically impossible. The latter can be accomplished by projecting the appearance of a critical investigation (notwithstanding that there is no underlying crime), turning administration officials into suspects, and hopefully generating the false-statement prosecutions that help depict the administration as dishonest and icky.

While all that plays out, though, behold the frightening thing Mueller’s investigation has become: a criminalization of politics. In the new order of things, policy differences are the grist for investigation and prosecution.
These are very third world, banana republic goings-on. Clearly a parting gift from the less-than-fully-American Obama administration.

Friday, December 1, 2017

The Flynn Plea

I've been scanning pundit reactions to the Michael Flynn guilty plea. I've concluded that doing so you learn more about the pundit than about the plea.

The Flynn plea is a sort of litmus test, if you despise Trump you believe it is the beginning of Trump's end. If you like Trump, you say (probably accurately) Flynn has pled guilty to the same lying for which he was fired shortly after the inauguration and amounts to little.

Several attorneys writing about the Flynn plea say he lied about behavior that was not itself illegal. I am puzzled why he should lie about doing lawful things.

I am even more puzzled about why he had anything to say to the FBI beyond his name, address, and date of birth. The fifth amendment to our Constitution protects against self-incrimination, had he merely "taken the fifth" he would be a free man today.

Free, that is, unless he was already provably "dirty" and they've decided not to charge him for really bad things he did in exchange for him rolling on his former boss. Possible, yes, but breath holding is not yet suggested.

Later ... this latter possibility begins to look more likely in the cold, grey light of dawn.

Thursday, November 30, 2017

When Not to Trust Science

The website Quillette carries an article concerning the willingness of scientists to self-censor, to suppress socially undesirable lines of inquiry or unpopular findings.
When a topic is politically contentious, and there is some risk to our reputation or career from endorsing a view, we may hang back and fail to either form a belief on that topic or publicly proclaim our allegiance to that belief.

The logic of collective action is that when the costs of expressing a belief are borne by the individual, but the benefits are shared among all members of an epistemic community, it is perfectly rational to fail to reveal our beliefs about that topic, no matter how justified they might be.

The case for deferring to scientific consensus on politically contentious topics is much weaker. This is true because what scientists publicly say may differ from what they privately believe. (snip) Some of the research that bears on a topic might not get done due to the fact that those who authorize or accept funding for it might incur reputational costs for working on a topic that is likely to produce results that most people don’t want to believe.
Let me share with you an example I know from roughly a half century ago at UC Berkeley. A friend who died recently was a psychology doctoral student there employed doing research the express aim of which was to demonstrate that various racial groups have essentially equal distributions of intelligence or IQ.

It was hoped to show that differences found heretofore were the result of cultural or linguistic differences. The researchers had a measure which appeared to be pre-linguistic and culture-free; they examined hundreds of preschoolers from all major racial groups in daycare in the Bay Area.

Sadly, their data showed exactly the same politically incorrect significant differences normally found with regular IQ tests taken by adults. Their disappointing study findings were never submitted for publication.

The data set was thrown away because socially desirable results were not produced. Wasting several years and hundreds of thousands of dollars was deemed preferable to being tarred with a "racist" label. The commitment of scientists to truth is somewhat less than total, it turns out.

Reigning in Hell

Instapundit Glenn Reynolds is on a roll today, check out his description of the lefty leadership of most of our large cities.
As the trajectory of many big cities has shown, their leaders would rather reign in Hell than serve in Heaven. So I don’t expect these policies to change from within. And I think creating “conditions peculiarly ideal for left-wing agitation,” is seen as a feature, not a bug.
I’m thinking Rahm Emanuel has found being Chicago’s mayor largely a reign in Hell. Sort of like being Admiral of the sewage lagoon. Can he possibly enjoy it?

Targets of Opportunity

Instapundit Glenn Reynolds writes something snarky, true, and laden with schadenfreude, making it a trifecta. His subject, the #MeToo unloading on male mashers.
As for where this came from all of a sudden, I think the deliberate effort to weaponize female anger — before, and especially after, the 2016 election — had a lot to do with it. It was aimed at Trump, but since Trump seems immune, it discharged into whatever targets were available. And the targets around Democratic women are mostly Democratic men.
Targets of opportunity ... ya gotta love the irony. They’re shooting the wounded.

Bye-ku for Rex

With h/t to popularizer James Taranto of The Wall Street Journal, we offer a bye-ku to Secretary of State Rex Tillerson. As noted below, the NYT is reporting he’s on the way out.

‘Bye Rex Tillerson,
A Trump homie you were not,
Retirement beckons.

A day later ... Peter Baker of NYT is usually plugged into good sources, but nobody at the WH or State will confirm. Perhaps Baker was used to send Tillerson a message that Trump doesn't want him deviating from the WH line, reminding him of the choice in the minilecture below.

Tillerson on Skids

The New York Times’ Peter Baker reports White House plans are underway to accept SecState Tillerson’s resignation sometime early next year, and replace him with CIA Director Mike Pompeo. If Baker’s intelligence is on the level, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR, no relation) will then take over the CIA directorship.

For those of us who’ve been paying attention, Tillerson and the President have often seemed to be of different opinions on important foreign affairs matters. This suggests Tillerson really doesn’t understand the SecState role.

PolySci Minilecture: In the executive branch, the President is the CEO, cabinet secretaries are his principal subordinates. They exist to manage their department and carry out the President’s policies. They have a right to be listened to, but no right to make policy with which the President disagrees. As in industry, a principal subordinate who disagrees with the boss has exactly two choices: enthusiastically advocate and implement presidential policy regardless of personal opinion, or resign.

One way or another, it appears we see this second option ripening, which suggests option one has become unpalatable. Perhaps Tillerson thought he could do it, maybe he was misled as to how much weight his opinions would be given. Honestly, it isn’t easy for a former CEO like Tillerson to be comfortable as second banana, especially to a flamboyant and opinionated boss like Trump.

Climate Models Overestimate Warming

The Daily Caller reports research findings showing global climate relatively stable, climate models overly sensitive.
University of Alabama-Huntsville climate scientists John Christy and Richard McNider found that by removing the climate effects of volcanic eruptions early on in the satellite temperature record it showed virtually no change in the rate of warming since the early 1990s.

Two major volcanoes — El Chichon in 1982 and Pinatubo in 1991 — caused global average temperature to dip as a result of volcanic ash, soot and debris reflecting sunlight back into space.

Those eruptions meant there was more subsequent warming in the following years, making the rate of warming appear to be rising as a result of man-made emissions or other factors, Christy said.

“Those eruptions happened relatively early in our study period, which pushed down temperatures in the first part of the dataset, which caused the overall record to show an exaggerated warming trend,” Christy said.
Not just a correction, but one that helps explain why earlier models have been overly sensitive.

You Are What You Drive

Due diligence: I love my F-350 4WD diesel pickup truck. It’s the most comfortable, practical, powerful and newest of the three motor vehicles we own. And it barely fits in our oversize garage.

The New York Post reports Stanford University research which shows a correlation between what you drive and how you vote. I don’t find this conclusion surprising at all.
When sedans outnumbered pickup trucks, there was an 88 percent chance the city would vote Democratic.

In areas with more pickup trucks, the odds switched to 82 percent in favor of Republicans, the researchers concluded.
The DrsC have joked about this for years. We’ve felt we could tell the politics of a region by whether parking spaces are big enough to accomodate full-sized pickups comfortably.

Classically, at our CA university the parking spaces were always too tight. Exactly what you’d expect in a hive of brie-eating, bicycle-loving socialists.

By contrast in WY, no problemo. WY has lots of room for pickups which are the modal vehicle and has lots of Republicans too. In some WY districts, Democrats don’t waste time fielding candidates for state legislator.

Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Bootleg Environmental Management

Lucianne.com has a link to a Smithsonian article about creative things occupants do to foil energy-saving features of supposedly "green" new buildings. Such buildings, the article notes, almost never produce the expected energy savings.

The article doesn't mention my favorite - having a small, portable electric heater hidden in a desk drawer or the bottom drawer of a filing cabinet. It was perfect for when the building didn't stay comfortably warm in winter as the thermostats in our university offices were designed so we couldn't adjust them.

For years I had a small heater in my office, a thing not technically permitted. The only person likely to see and report it was the night janitor so I put it away when I went home.

Mine certainly wasn't the only one. There were likely a dozen or more in my building alone, one of a score of such buildings. Many offices, including mine, also housed a small refrigerator and a microwave. We couldn't hide these but nobody complained and I had cold soda or hot soup as needed.

We Oversexed Anthropoids

Take the news this morning that NBC has fired Matt Lauer, co-host of the Today Show. Add the cascade of #MeToo revelations that began with Harvey Weinstein, the harassment on Capitol Hill and the problems Roman Catholics have had with pedophilic priestly misbehavior.

Splice on Bill Clinton’s zipper malfunctions and the fact in some demographics most children are born out of wedlock. Don’t overlook the untold numbers of babies we kill each year, euphemistically calling it “choice.”

The poor job we humans do of managing our reproductive (and associated recreational) behavior is stunning. Men abuse women and other men, women abuse men and other women, both abuse children and the aged. Even animals occasionally gain our unwanted attention. And yet, because of, or in spite of, all the activity, many have needs unmet or are scarred in the attempt.

It is altogether not a pretty picture. The scope of the collective problem is enormous. Our efforts at even a partial solution seem insignificant by comparison. I don’t expect answers anytime soon, perhaps not in the lifetime of any of us, perhaps never.

You have to wonder if unbridled, freeform horniness is the price we humans must pay to keep our species extant. It seems likely.

Later ... breaking news ... Minnesota Public Radio has announced they've fired long-time Prairie Home Companion host Garrison Keillor for "inappropriate behavior." What other icons are about to crumble, one wonders?

I conclude folks in show biz and politics are even worse than my late father claimed. He swore they were nearly all low-life pond scum.

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

Insight

The New York Daily News reports an interview Denzel Washington gave while promoting his new film Roman J. Israel, Esq. Asked about the justice system, he replied:
It starts at home. It starts with how you raise your children. If a young man doesn’t have a father figure, he’ll go find a father figure. So you know I can’t blame the system. It’s unfortunate that we make such easy work for them.
The mirror is not a popular place to look for the source of one's problems. Often the right place, but almost never popular.

Cokie's Kerfuffle

Many sources are reporting ABC News/NPR analyst Cokie Roberts said on This Week it was well-known among Washington news gals not to get in an elevator with Rep. Conyers (D-MI).

Instead of taking others' word for what Roberts said, here is what actually went down, from the program transcript. We begin with host Martha Raddatz:
And what about Conyers and Franken? Nothing's happened since. What happens to them?
This is followed by quite a bit of back and forth cynical comment by panelists Palmer, Klein, and Roberts about the relaxed culture of Congress vis-a-vis sexual harassment, with no names mentioned. Then Roberts says:
Don't get in the elevator with him, you know, and the whole every female in the press corps knew that, right, don't get in elevator with him. Now people are saying it out loud. And I think that does make a difference.
It isn't clear if Roberts speaks about Conyers specifically, or about any number of dirty old men in Congress. You could conclude either. My guess is she meant Conyers, but now regrets her candor.

I wouldn't necessarily take Roberts' word for her intent, after she's had an opportunity to reflect on the non-PC impact of her words. She hasn't kept a decades-long relationship with left-wing NPR by being tough on Democrats.