Wednesday, December 7, 2022

Consent of the Governed


The people of two totalitarian nations have been engaging in protests recently: in Iran the issue concerns the oppressive religious police and in China it concerns the oppressive Covid quarantines. In both cases there is at least some evidence here and here that the governments are backing down. 

This is further proof, if any is needed, that even repressive governments exist with the tacit consent of the governed and at some level recognize that fact. It is a lesson one hopes Russia’s Putin is healthy enough to understand as he pursues an increasingly unpopular-at-home war in Ukraine.

It is a strength of elected governments that the consent of the governed is explicitly sought and periodically calibrated, however imperfectly, via elections. Thus, in places with elected governments it is normal for people to lose power without losing their lives in the bargain, something not often possible in totalitarian regimes.